The governments oppressive rule is criticized in respected relationships among the characters in 1984 and v for vendetta between winston and julia, and evey and v. In piecemeal, it serves warnings, but the aspects outlined are required to be present all at the. The brand name of items in 1984 was victory v and v in v for vendetta was striking for a victory. Both works are juvenalian satires against totalitarian governments, namely the. They are trampled upon for a time, yet seldom do they fail of their seed, and that will. From what i remember george orwells dystopian novel 1984 was big news. Both of these novels are similar in a way like the themes and how the male protagonists are the one in charge of overturning the government. V for vendetta is based on the graphic novel written by alan moore and illustrated by. Why did v blow up parliament in v for vendetta the movie.
Im disappointed about the former, but indifferent about the latter. The book 1984 is a dystopian novel written by george orwell that was published in 1949. Since im always interested in resources that might make orwells. Orwell was penning this novel in an age of totalitarianism, mainly in spain, germany, and the soviet union. Michael radfords 1984 part 1 the privations of an alternative past. Oppressive governments and the psychological manipulation of the people are the strong themes and warning signs that these two powerful works of art, 1984 and v for vendetta, attempt to delineate. V for vendetta 1984 comparison essay 2306 words cram. That film is based on the critically acclaimed and commercially successful graphic novel written by alan moore, concerned with the revolutionary antics of antihero v as he battles against a totalitarian regime in a dystopian british society. Many have pondered with a tinge of sadness on the ephemerality of existence. V for vendetta is a 2006 americangerman political thriller film directed by james mcteigue. Compare and contrast essay 1984 and v for vendetta speech.
They named it v for vendetta, they molded its hero after the guy fawkes. Display a society where the government manipulates the lives of their citizens. If you have read 1984 and seen the film v for vendetta then please mention comparisons about the two. Compare and contrast the novels 1984 and v for vendetta. But in v for vendetta as well as 1984, the law was enforced at night. Both take place in a dystopian world both in london, even. After finally reading it, though, im inclined to say the level of oppression present in the book just isnt possible. What are the differences between vendetta and 1984 answers. Betrayal v tortured evey by, winston told obrien to make the rats eat her face instead of his.
The reason each government could have the surveillance they did is because of the amount of power they had. Alex and i argued in class about who resembled winston of 1984 in v for vendetta. Initially published, starting in 1982, in blackandwhite as an ongoing serial in the shortlived uk anthology warrior, it morphed into a tenissue limited series published by dc comics. On a severity scale of 1 to 10, v for vendetta would probably rate an 8, while the severity of the situation in 1984 has been turned up to 11.
In both 1984 and v for vendetta, the information given to the public is written. Focusing on the government, both ridicule the governments manipulation of history, their use of distorting emotions, and brutality towards. Classic literature, original gangster s1 e4 1984 nineteen eightyfour thug notes summary and analysis duration. And somehow when i read the book 1984 i kept relating the whole plot of the book to the comic book. V for vendetta is alan moores graphic novel about anarchist v combating the. Similar censorship v for vendetta audio sweeps and news alteration, 1984 thought police and. In dystopian novels, the story is most often set in a land wherein. There are lots of similarity to be found between 1984 and v for vendetta. Both protagonists in v for vendetta and 1984 wish to overturn their current government. Comparecontrast 1984 and v for vendetta lets make a list first. In some ways, v for vendetta resembles the french revolution more than it resembles oceania in 1984.
In nineteen eightyfour, technological development is restricted as a means of social control. Subsequent collected editions have been typically published under dcs more. Compare and contrast the novels 1984 and v for vendetta dystopia. Compare and contrast essay 1984 and v for vendetta speech compare and contrast essay 1984 and v for vendetta speech what makes a good cricket bat. I dont know how to put it into words as i have to write an essay comparing the 2. V for vendetta models of rebellion in 1984 and v for vendetta joseph latorcai 12th grade. The link from v for vendetta to 1984 grows substantially with each passing scene yet still differentiating itself from the classic novel at the same time big brother, with his stalin like features, is an iconic figure in george orwells 1984 as is the inner party. However v for vendetta was based on 1984 since 1984 was written before v for vendetta.
Its a world where old things have not just sentimental value, they are a symbol of liberty the antique shop in 1984, gordons secret room in v. Comparison between 1984 and v for vendetta by prezi user. In addition, nighttime is often when people are most vulnerable, because it is generally the time of day in which we sleep, rest, prepare for the next day. Its a world where total surveillance is the foundation of the society. The first similarity that i realized is the story background setting between those two. Winston and julia go to see brien and he enlists them into the brotherhood, a secret group dedicated to fighting huge brother. The proles in both 1984 and v for vendetta are powerful and unchanged due to their humanity, giving them an advantage for a potential rebellion. Regarding the movies 1984and v for vendetta, the main concern of this thesis is. Comparing and contrasting 1984 and v for vendetta 886. V for vendetta is a comic book written by alan moore. Since the book 1984 was written previous to v for vendetta, so maybe v for vendetta may well have based some of its ideas on this book.
Today marks the release of the wachowski brothers new film, v for vendetta. In both satires, 1984 and v for vendetta the concept of humanity is. Focusing on the future societies, the governments and all that stuff. V for vendetta, a satirical film directed by james mcteigue, revolves around the actions of an antihero named v and his struggles to reestablish humanity in individuals by rebelling against the governments rule. V for vendetta is a british graphic novel written by alan moore and illustrated by david lloyd with additional art by tony weare. V for vendetta is about a government who has a leader that controls everything from the media to what the people could eat. In v for vendetta you see a masked vigilante proactively fighting to destroy the totalitarian fascist government that is in charge. The first similarity between 1984 and v for vendetta is that the society is being run by totalitarian rule. Lloyds v for vendetta comic book series 19821989 in which, as in 1984. V for vendetta has cameras everywhere in order to conduct mass surveillance over the citizens, which is comparable to how the telescreens watched over the citizens in 1984. Problems faced by characters in literature often repeat themselves, and when these characters decide to solve these standard problems, their actions are often more similar than they first appear. Since the book 1984 was written before v for vendetta, so perhaps v for vendetta may have based some of its ideas on this book. This idea is evident when comparing the actions taken by. The idea that governments rely on the conformity of society, to secure power, is being strongly criticized in 1984 and v for vendetta.
V s aggressive acts against his government are successful in crippling the government as opposed to wintons passive. What are the similarities and differences of george orwells 1984. What are the similarities and differences of george orwell. In 1984, the humanity of the relationship between winston and julia is a rebellion in itself. Additionally, the book and film take place in dystopian england, under the. Since im always interested in resources that might make orwells important warning clear to younger people, growing up as they are in a world that is so shaped by newspeak and doublethinknow referred to as political correctnessthat his message is hard for them to hear, i watched the film. Where 1984 pits sovietera communism against socialism, v for vendetta watches as fascism. Several students have told me that the film v for vendetta is just like 1984. To be honest, i have only seen the movie of v for vendetta. The irony and constant ridicule is what makes both v for vendetta and 1984 great satires. Writing a compare and contrast essay on 1984 and v for vendetta. Compare and contrast essay comparing 1984 with v for vendetta both 1984 by george orwell and v for vendetta directed by james mcteigue depict dystopian totalitarian societies. Both of them have very strict politic system and the governments are able to fully control their people. Free essays on compare and contrast 1984 and v for.
In nineteen eightyfour, the very essence of language as a tool of though. Both 1984 and v for vendetta have similarities like the way the themes and how the male. That book did more than all the speeches, all the advertisements and all the politicians to change the climate of public opinion in england. Power is an encompassing theme in both 1984 and v for vendetta.
Marys virus many individuals were angry about the power the government has and desired to rebel. Comparing and contrasting 1984 and v for vendetta the novel 1984 and the graphic novel v for vendetta have similar views on how society is being run. This is the novelisation of the 2006 film v for vendetta. When comparing the two stories, we can definitively see that there is a similarity in storyline.
This paper will be comparing these two fictional dystopian governments to the. In the end, the novel 1984 simply depicts a more severe version of the same society described in the film v for vendetta. There are definite similarities between them yet they are in no way identical which makes them perfect candidates for a compare and contrast essay. Whats the relationship between the movie v for vendetta. Similarities and differences of v for vendetta and 1984. Orwell highlights the future, telling the past and present comparison. Literature is full of curveballs and similarities, but when it comes to a very intense piece of literature like 1984, you can easily find a similar plot and storyline in anoth er piece of work, such as v for vendetta. Based on the graphic novel by alan moore, v imagines a british empire under totalitarian rule.
V for vendetta essay models of rebellion in 1984 and v. How is the movie v for vendetta related to the book 1984. He said the inspector was winston and i argued gordon. Yes, the graphic novel series v for vendetta by alan moore is very much like the novel 1984 by george orwell. Since the book 1984 was written before v for vendetta.
1219 59 307 237 1080 861 148 1366 1405 1385 1235 1139 857 641 1205 1078 598 978 220 229 944 881 1306 1041 1177 160 281 368 646 1201 43